How to Choose the Right Digital Marketing Agency for Your Business


In today’s fast-paced digital landscape, finding the right digital marketing agency can be a game-changer for your business. With a plethora of options available, it’s crucial to make an informed decision that aligns with your goals and values. This article will guide you through the process of choosing the ideal digital marketing agency for your business, ensuring a successful partnership that can elevate your brand’s online presence.

Setting Goals and Defining Your Business Needs

Before diving into the search for your ideal digital marketing agency, it’s essential to lay the foundation. Imagine that you’re embarking on a road trip, and before you hit the road, you plan your destination, routes, and pit stops. In the same way, before you begin your journey to find the right digital marketing agency, take a moment to introspect. 

  • What is the ultimate destination for your business? 
  • Where do you see it in the long run? 
  • How does digital marketing fit into this grand scheme? 

Just like a GPS needs a destination, your business needs clear goals. Whether it’s increasing online sales, expanding your brand’s reach, or nurturing a loyal customer base, defining your objectives is your roadmap to success. 

For example, envision a mid-sized e-commerce store aiming to boost its annual revenue by 40% in the next year. This clear goal will not only guide your agency search but also allow you to measure the agency’s effectiveness in helping you reach that destination. So, before you set off on your journey to find the right digital marketing agency, take a moment to set your GPS – your Goals, Plans, and Strategies.

hiring marketing agency

Hire Agency or Create an In-House Team

When it comes to assembling the dream team for your digital marketing endeavors, there are two primary paths to consider: hiring a digital marketing agency or building an in-house team. Both options have their unique advantages, so it’s crucial to weigh them against your specific business situation and objectives.

Hiring an Agency

Hiring a digital marketing agency offers numerous advantages that can be highly beneficial for businesses of all sizes. Here are some of the key pros of hiring a digital marketing agency:

  • Expertise and Specialization: Digital marketing agencies typically have teams of specialists with expertise in various areas of digital marketing, such as SEO, social media, content marketing, PPC advertising, conversion rate optimization, email marketing, data analysis, etc. This expertise can lead to more effective and targeted campaigns.
  • Access to a Diverse Skill Set: Agencies often employ professionals with a wide range of skills and experiences gained from working with diverse clients and industries. This diversity can bring fresh perspectives and innovative ideas to your marketing strategies.
  • Cost-Efficiency: Hiring an agency can be cost-effective compared to maintaining a full in-house marketing team. You can avoid the costs associated with hiring, training, salaries, benefits, and overhead expenses.
  • Scalability: Agencies can quickly scale their services up or down to meet your changing marketing needs. This flexibility is especially valuable for seasonal campaigns or sudden shifts in business goals.
  • Advanced Tools and Technology: Agencies typically have access to cutting-edge tools, software, and analytics platforms that might be costly for businesses to acquire and maintain on their own. This can result in more data-driven and effective campaigns.
  • Focus on Core Competencies: Outsourcing marketing allows your team to focus on core business functions and what you do best, while leaving the marketing strategies and execution to the experts.
  • Efficiency and Speed: Agencies are often more efficient at executing marketing campaigns due to their experience and resources. This can lead to quicker results and faster campaign implementation.
  • Objective Perspective: An external agency can provide an objective viewpoint on your marketing strategies and campaigns, helping you avoid tunnel vision and make more informed decisions.
  • Measurable Results: Digital marketing agencies emphasize data-driven strategies and provide detailed reporting and analysis. This allows you to measure the success of your campaigns and make data-informed adjustments.
  • Industry Insights and Trends: Agencies often have a broad network and access to industry-specific data and trends. This knowledge can help your business stay competitive and adapt to changing market conditions.
  • Reduced Risk: By outsourcing marketing functions to a reputable agency, you reduce the risk associated with hiring and training in-house staff. You also benefit from the agency’s experience in managing marketing campaigns.
  • Focus on Core Business Goals: Partnering with an agency allows you to focus on your core business objectives while the agency handles the intricacies of marketing, ensuring alignment with your overall business goals.

To sum up, hiring a digital marketing agency can provide your business with access to a wealth of expertise, resources, and tools that can lead to more effective and efficient marketing campaigns. It’s important to carefully evaluate agencies based on their track record, industry experience, and cultural fit to ensure a successful partnership.

in house marketing team

Building an In-House Team

Pros of Having an In-House Marketing Team

When considering your digital marketing strategy, an in-house marketing team can offer several compelling advantages:

  • Full Control: With an in-house team, you retain complete control over your marketing efforts. You can handpick the talent, shape their strategies, and oversee the day-to-day operations, ensuring that every aspect aligns perfectly with your business objectives and values.
  • Cultural Fit: Your in-house marketing team becomes an integral part of your organization’s culture. They understand your brand ethos, mission, and vision on a deeper level, which naturally translates into more authentic and aligned marketing campaigns. This cultural harmony can resonate better with your target audience.
  • Efficient Communication: Proximity matters when it comes to communication. When your marketing team works in-house, communication is not hindered by geographical or time zone differences. It’s easier to facilitate quick meetings, brainstorming sessions, and real-time feedback, leading to faster decision-making and agile responses to market dynamics.
  • Alignment with Sales: The synergy between marketing and sales is crucial for driving revenue. Having both functions under the same roof fosters seamless collaboration. Sales teams can provide valuable insights into customer preferences and pain points, helping marketers tailor their strategies.
  • Immediate Response: In today’s fast-paced digital landscape, opportunities and challenges can arise at a moment’s notice. An in-house team can react swiftly to emerging trends, competitor actions, or customer feedback. This agility allows your business to stay ahead in the market and capitalize on trends before they become saturated.

While these advantages make in-house teams an attractive choice, it’s essential to weigh them against the potential drawbacks, such as higher operational costs and limited diversity in expertise. The decision between an in-house team and partnering with a digital marketing agency should align with your specific business needs and long-term objectives.

higher costs inhouse marketing team

Cons of having an in-house marketing team

While having an in-house marketing team can be advantageous in many ways, it’s essential to consider the potential drawbacks or cons:

  • Higher Costs: Maintaining an in-house marketing team can be expensive. You’ll need to budget for salaries, benefits, office space, training, and ongoing development. This can be particularly challenging for smaller or mid-sized businesses with limited financial resources.
  • Limited Expertise: In-house teams may lack the depth and breadth of expertise found in specialized marketing agencies. Agencies often have professionals with diverse skills and experience gained from working with various clients and industries.
  • Resource Constraints: Building a capable in-house team requires time and resources for recruitment and onboarding. It can take a while to assemble a team with the right skills and cultural fit, potentially delaying marketing initiatives.
  • Limited Scalability: In-house teams may struggle to quickly scale up or down in response to changing marketing needs. During periods of high demand or specialized projects, you might find it challenging to find and hire temporary or contract staff.
  • Risk of Tunnel Vision: In-house teams may become too focused on internal perspectives and lose sight of external market dynamics and trends. External agencies often bring fresh insights and ideas to the table.
  • Dependency on Key Employees: If key members of your in-house team leave, it can disrupt your marketing efforts. You may need to invest time and resources in recruiting and training replacements.
  • Lack of Objectivity: In-house teams may struggle with objectivity when evaluating their own work or the company’s marketing strategies. An external agency can provide a more impartial assessment.
  • Reduced Network and Industry Insights: Agencies often have a broad network and access to industry-specific data and trends. In-house teams might miss out on valuable industry insights that external agencies can provide.
  • Overhead and Administrative Burden: Managing an in-house team comes with administrative tasks such as HR management, payroll, and performance evaluations. This administrative burden can divert attention from core marketing activities.
  • Potential for Groupthink: In-house teams may be more susceptible to groupthink, where team members conform to the prevailing opinions within the organization. This can limit creativity and innovation.

It’s essential to carefully evaluate these potential cons against the specific needs and resources of your business. Many businesses opt for a hybrid approach, combining an in-house team with external agency partnerships to leverage the strengths of both models while mitigating their respective weaknesses.

The Pillars of Informed Decision-Making

Digital Marketing Agency Portfolio, Client Reviews, and Business Cases

When it comes to choosing the right digital marketing agency, you’re not merely making a choice; you’re forging a partnership that can shape the future of your business. This decision demands careful consideration, and that’s where digital marketing agency portfolio, client reviews, and business cases become your guiding beacons.

  • Demonstrated Expertise: A portfolio showcases the agency’s past work and demonstrates their expertise in various areas of digital marketing. It provides tangible evidence of their ability to deliver results. For instance, consider our approach with one client, a firewood company. They were facing the challenge of transitioning to e-commerce, and we crafted a custom strategy driven by a dedicated marketing team. By identifying the ideal customer, harnessing the power of pay-per-click advertising, simplifying the user experience, and meticulously tracking ROI, we achieved outstanding outcomes. In just six months, the company saw a remarkable 484% increase in revenue, showcasing the potential of a well-executed strategy.
  • Relevant Experience: By reviewing the agency’s portfolio, you can assess whether they have experience in your specific industry or niche. An agency with industry-specific experience may better understand your target audience and market dynamics. Another case in point is our work with an SEO challenge of a small family-owned company manufacturing window wells. Through deep research, sophisticated methods, and keyword mapping, we boosted lead generation by 115%. These compelling results are prominently featured in our portfolios and reviews, offering a clear picture of our capabilities.
  • Quality of Work: Portfolios allow you to evaluate the quality of the agency’s work. You can assess the design, content, and overall effectiveness of their past campaigns, websites, and content. In an impossible market, our agency’s performance speaks volumes. In a strictly regulated industry where advertising is discouraged, we used innovative tactics, customer understanding, and technology to increase market share, yielding a 350% revenue increase in just four years.

These real-world business cases underscore the importance of choosing a digital marketing agency with a track record of turning challenges into triumphs, as showcased in their portfolios and reviews. They not only demonstrate the agency’s abilities but also serve as a source of inspiration and ideas for your own marketing campaigns. This wealth of information allows you to gauge cultural fit, transparency, and accountability, ensuring a harmonious partnership that aligns with your business goals and expectations.

In summary, digital marketing agency portfolio, client reviews, and business cases offer valuable insights into an agency’s track record, capabilities, and ability to deliver results, making them essential pillars of informed decision-making.

digital marketing agency price

Pricing Considerations

The cost of hiring a digital marketing agency can vary significantly depending on several factors. Digital marketing agency pricing is not one-size-fits-all, as it depends on your specific needs, goals, industry, location, and the agency’s level of expertise. Here are some factors that can influence the cost of hiring a digital marketing agency:

  • Scope of Services: The types of services you require will have a major impact on cost. Common services include SEO, content marketing, social media management, PPC advertising, email marketing, web design, and more. The more services you need, the higher the cost.
  • Complexity of Your Project: The complexity of your marketing project can affect pricing. For example, a simple local SEO campaign may cost less than a comprehensive international SEO strategy.
  • Geographic Location: The geographic location of the agency can influence pricing. Agencies in larger cities or regions with a higher cost of living may charge more for their services than those in smaller towns.
  • Agency Expertise and Reputation: Established agencies with a strong reputation and a track record of success often charge higher fees. However, their expertise can lead to more effective campaigns and a better return on investment.
  • Duration of the Engagement: Some agencies charge on a monthly retainer basis, while others work on a project-by-project basis. The longer the engagement, the more you may be able to negotiate lower monthly fees.
  • Size of Your Business: The size and revenue of your business can influence pricing. Larger businesses with more extensive marketing needs may pay more than smaller businesses.
  • Performance-Based Pricing: Some agencies offer performance-based pricing models where their fees are tied to specific results, such as increased website traffic, leads, or sales. This can be a win-win arrangement if the agency delivers on its promises.
  • Customization: Customized marketing strategies tailored to your specific goals and target audience may cost more than cookie-cutter solutions.
  • Industry Competition: Highly competitive industries may require more aggressive and costly marketing strategies to stand out.
  • Additional Costs: Be aware of potential additional costs, such as advertising spend (for PPC campaigns), software and tool expenses, and content creation fees.

As a rough estimate, monthly retainers for digital marketing services can range from a few hundred dollars for small businesses to several thousand dollars or more for larger enterprises with extensive marketing needs. It’s crucial to have a clear discussion with potential agencies about your budget and objectives to get a customized quote that aligns with your specific requirements. Additionally, some agencies may offer flexible pricing models or even performance-based pricing, so it’s worth exploring different options to find the best fit for your business.

preparing for meeting

Preparing for the Initial Meeting: Crafting a Path to Success

In the quest to find the perfect digital marketing agency, the initial meeting is your chance to lay the foundation for a fruitful partnership. Imagine this: you’re sitting across from a potential agency partner, whether in person or virtually, and the conversation is about to begin. To ensure this encounter is as productive as possible, preparation is key. Here’s a closer look at how to get the most out of this crucial meeting:

  • Sharing Past Experiences: Before diving into the nitty-gritty of your digital marketing needs, it’s valuable to provide some context. Mention any previous experiences with marketing companies, agencies, or consultants.
    • What worked well in those relationships? 
    • Were there aspects you particularly appreciated? 
    • On the flip side, what left you wanting more? 

Sharing these insights offers a glimpse into your expectations and preferences, helping the agency tailor their approach to your unique needs.

Example: Let’s say you previously collaborated with a marketing agency that excelled in content creation but struggled with transparent reporting. By highlighting this experience, you signal to the potential agency what aspects of collaboration are non-negotiable for you, such as clear and regular reporting.

  • Defining Success Metrics: One of the critical elements of a successful partnership is a shared understanding of success. Explain how you measure success in your business. What key performance indicators (KPIs) matter most to you? Is it all about driving website traffic, converting leads, increasing social media engagement, or boosting sales revenue? Lay out your expectations clearly so that the agency can align their strategies and efforts with your specific goals.
  • Cultural Alignment Matters: While expertise is crucial, a harmonious partnership extends beyond the technical aspects of marketing. It’s about culture too. Ensure that the agency’s cultural values align with those of your organization.
    • Do they share your commitment to transparency, responsiveness, and collaboration? 
    • Is their communication style a good fit for your business? 

When the agency’s culture resonates with yours, it sets the stage for a seamless working relationship.

In essence, the initial meeting is your chance to paint a clear picture of your business, your expectations, and your cultural values. By providing this valuable context, you enable the agency to craft a tailored strategy that aligns perfectly with your goals and sets the stage for a prosperous collaboration.

Bringing the Agency on Board: A Strategic Partnership

When you embark on the journey to select the right digital marketing agency for your business, you’re not just choosing a service provider—you’re inviting a strategic partner into your fold. The ideal agency should seamlessly integrate into your team, striving to understand your business intricately and sharing your aspirations for success. 

Take us, at Shtrack, for instance. Here, the approach transcends the conventional client-agency relationship. It’s about forging long-lasting partnerships that stand the test of time. In some cases, these partnerships have spanned over a decade, solidifying our role as not just an agency but as strategic allies. We dive deep, mining data to craft growth strategies that are not just intuitive but backed by numbers. Our seasoned consultants offer insights that empower you to make informed decisions and achieve your loftiest business goals. It’s more than collaboration; it’s a shared journey towards excellence.

beyond the beer test

Building Connections: Beyond the Beer Test

As you navigate the landscape of selecting the ideal digital marketing agency, there’s a valuable litmus test you shouldn’t underestimate—the metaphorical “Beer Test.” It’s not about the beverage itself; it’s about the genuine connection, the synergy, and the partnership potential with the agency’s team. 

Envision an evening where work attire is replaced by casual conversation, where business jargon gives way to friendly banter. Could you see yourself comfortably sharing that moment with them? This test is far more than a social exercise; it’s about gauging the quality of the working relationship.

Sure, expertise and technical prowess are non-negotiable, but there’s another dimension that often spells the difference between a successful collaboration and a missed opportunity. It’s about finding a team with whom you can effortlessly communicate and share ideas. It’s about trust, open dialogue, and a shared commitment to your business’s success.

In the world of digital marketing, where strategies evolve, and challenges arise, the strength of your partnership can make all the difference. It’s the ability to brainstorm together, adapt to changing landscapes, and celebrate victories as a united front. When you find an agency that not only excels in their field but also aligns with your values and work culture, you’re not just choosing a service provider; you’re fostering a relationship that paves the way for exceptional outcomes.

So, remember, it’s not merely about sharing a beer—it’s about sharing a vision, a mission, and the journey to achieve your digital marketing goals together. Here’s to building connections that stand the test of time and propel your business to new heights.

And when it comes to building such connections, you can rely on us at Shtrack. We offer you the opportunity to embrace a 1-Month partnership and pay only if you’re satisfied. We’re so confident in our ability to drive results that we’re making this unique offer. Hire us for one month, and if you’re not thrilled with our services, you pay nothing. It’s that simple – no strings attached. 

Let’s embark on this journey together towards digital marketing success. Join hands with Shtrack, and let’s make your digital dreams a reality. Book a free consultation with us today to discuss your marketing needs and how we can assist you.

Enjoyed the article?

Elevate your business with our expert insights. Subscribe for valuable tips that make a difference!